‘Opiophobia’ Has Left Africa In Agony


Mr. Bizimungu at a hospice in Kampala. He takes bottled morphine at a weaker strength, which still makes all the difference. “Without it, I would be dead,” he said. CreditCharlie Shoemaker for The New York Times

KAMPALA, UGANDA (THE NEW YORK TIMES) — Pain is only the latest woe in John Bizimungu’s life.

Rwandan by birth, he has lived here as a refugee since his family was slaughtered in the 1994 genocide. A cobbler, Mr. Bizimungu used to walk the streets asking people if he could fix their shoes.

Now, at 75 and on crutches, he sits at home hoping customers will drop by. But at least the searing pain from the cancer that has twisted his right foot is under control.

“Oh! Grateful? I am so, so, so, so grateful for the morphine!” he said, waving his hands and rocking back in his chair. “Without it, I would be dead.”

Mr. Bizimungu’s morphine is an opioid, closely related to the painkillers now killing 60,000 Americans a year — a situation President Trump recently declared a “health emergency.”

The cobbler’s desperate need exemplifies a problem that deeply worries palliative care experts: how they can help the 25 million people who die in agony each year in poor and middle-income countries without risking an American-style overdose epidemic abroad or triggering opposition from Western legislators and philanthropists for whom “opioid” has become a dirty word.

The American delegation to the International Narcotics Control Board, a United Nations agency, “uses frightening war-on-drugs rhetoric,” said Meg O’Brien, the founder of Treat the Pain, an advocacy group devoted to bringing palliative care to poor countries.

“That has a chilling effect on developing countries,” she said. “But it’s ridiculous — the U.S. also has an obesity epidemic, but no one is proposing that we withhold food aid from South Sudan.”

Uganda has implemented an innovative solution. Here, liquid morphine is produced by a private charity overseen by the government. And with doctors in short supply, the law lets even nurses prescribe morphine after specialized training.

About 11 percent of Ugandans needing morphine get it. Inadequate as that is, it makes Uganda a standout not just in Africa, but in the world.

Yet there is very little opioid abuse here; alcohol, marijuana and khat are far bigger problems.
No Relief in Sight

A recent major study by The Lancet Commission on Global Access to Palliative Care and Pain Relief described a “broad and deep abyss” in access to painkillers between rich countries and poor ones.

The United States, the report said, produces or imports 31 times as much narcotic pain-relievers it needs whether in legal or illegal form: morphine, hydrocodone, heroin, methadone, fentanyl and so on.

Haiti, by contrast, gets slightly less than 1 percent of what it needs. And Nigeria, on a per-capita basis, gets only a quarter of what Haiti gets: 0.2 percent of its need.

Even in big countries with domestic pharmaceutical industries, citizens still get shortchanged on pain relief, the report said. India and Indonesia, the second- and fourth-most populous countries on the planet, each supply only 4 percent of their own needs. Russia is at 8 percent. China, at 16 percent, barely beats Uganda.

“Each country has its own barriers,” said Dr. James F. Cleary, director of pain and policy studies at the University of Wisconsin’s medical school and a member of the commission that produced the Lancet study.

In some countries, doctors get no palliative care training; in others, legislators or the police oppose importing narcotics or deliberately make prescribing them difficult because of what the report deems “opiophobia.”

Pharmaceutical companies are uninterested in selling the generic morphine needed by poor countries because it is cheap and yields little profit.

Enough morphine to treat the entire world for end-of-life suffering would cost only $145 million a year, the Lancet report found.

Moreover, to treat all the children underage 15 needing it — for severe burns, surgery, car accidents, pain from sickle cell disease, cancerous tumors crushing spinal cords and so on — would cost a mere $1 million.

“This is a pittance,” the authors wrote, “compared with the $100 billion a year the world’s governments spend on enforcing global prohibition of drug use.”

Some pharmaceutical companies do try to market patented time-release oxycodone and other highly profitable opioids in middle-income countries — but governments are often wary because of the epidemic of drug abuse that has swept the United States.

“You only have to see one Time magazine cover, and countries say, ‘This isn’t something we want,’” Dr. Cleary said.

Demand for pain relief “needs a champion in each country,” said Felicia Marie Knaul, a health economist at the University of Miami and lead author of the Lancet report.

“Most people don’t want to talk about pain and dying,” she said. “And what makes it different from cancer is that the people who need it most are right about to die, and then they can’t speak out.”
How Uganda Succeeded

Uganda has had a national pain-relief policy since the mid-1990s. It succeeded for several reasons:

¶ The policy had outspoken local champions: Dr. Anne Merriman, a former missionary nun who in 1993 founded Hospice Africa Uganda to care for the terminally ill; Rose Kiwanuka, the first nurse trained in palliative care in this country, who now heads the Palliative Care Association of Uganda; and Dr. Jack Jagwe, a health ministry official who recognized the need.

(Like much of Africa, Uganda was in the grip of an AIDS epidemic in 1993 that seemed unstoppable because antiretroviral drugs then cost $12,000 a year. Many victims died screaming in pain from cryptococcal meningitis, Kaposi’s sarcoma or other opportunistic infections.)

Uganda’s president, Yoweri Museveni, who has been in office since 1986, accepted the import of opioids after Dr. Jagwe endorsed them. Mr. Museveni’s response to AIDS was also forward-thinking; when other presidents were denying their countries even had it, he pioneered “ABC prevention” — Abstain/Be Faithful/Use Condoms.

¶ And perhaps most important: the only opioid the government permits outside hospitals is pint bottles of morphine diluted in water. The drug is distributed free, at government expense, undercutting incentives for pharmaceutical companies to fight for market share.

The bottled morphine comes in two strengths: 0.5 gram or 5 grams per 500 milliliters. Even the weaker one dulls the pain suffered by Mr. Bizimungu, who is succumbing slowly to a form of Kaposi’s sarcoma that is not triggered by H.I.V.

The bottles are a simple and ingenious way to prevent addiction. Getting high would require drinking gallons of the bitter, slightly nauseating solution. Distilling enough morphine to inject would require boiling away gallons.

“You can drink a whole bottle and all you’d get is some nausea and constipation, and be sleepy,” said Rinty Kintu, the Uganda coordinator at Treat the Pain.

At the Cancer Charity Foundation, a hospice for adults with cancer in Kampala, liquid morphine is easing the last days of John Kanakura, 55, whose colon cancer has spread to his liver.

“Since the cancer started about a year and a half ago, I have never really gotten relief,” said Mr. Kanakura, who raised three children on his small farm after his wife left. “It is like someone is cutting me with a knife.”

Mr. Kanakura’s daily bottle gives him about eight hours of pain relief, letting him get some sleep, his son, Philip Mutabazi, 18, said.

Morphine is not prescribed nearly as freely in Uganda as opioids have been in the United States.

“The U.S.’s addiction problem didn’t come out of cancer wards, it came out of orthopedics and dental,” said Dr. O’Brien. “Developing countries don’t give opioids for sprained ankles or wisdom tooth extractions.”
Early Opposition

In a telephone interview from Scotland, Dr. Merriman, sometimes called Uganda’s “mother of palliative care,” described the early days of mixing morphine powder imported from Europe in buckets with water boiled on the kitchen stove.

Once cool, it was poured into empty mineral water bottles scrounged from tourist hotels.

She also recalled early opposition from older doctors who equated giving morphine to dying patients with euthanasia.

“You need someone to shout and scream and keep it going,” Dr. Merriman said.

Initially, donors like the Diana, Princess of Wales Memorial Fund and George Soros’s Open Society Institute helped, and the British and American governments provided money to help dying AIDS patients. But those funds slowly dried up as drugs for AIDS became more available.

Some hospitals began mixing their own morphine solutions. Then a morphine shortage occurred in 2010 following price squabbling between the health ministry and private wholesalers.

In 2011 the national drug warehouse was made the sole legal importer of morphine powder, and Hospice Africa was asked to mix solution for the whole country.

Treat the Pain stepped in to help. Its founder, Dr. O’Brien, a former epidemiologist at the Clinton Health Access Initiative, said she created the nonprofit after reading a 2007 New York Times series describing how millions died without pain relief and hearing an H.I.V. doctor describe his patients screaming in pain.

The nonprofit, which is now part of the American Cancer Society, paid about $100,000 for machines to sterilize water, make plastic bottles, fill them and attach labels.

Further mechanization is needed. On a recent visit to the operation, a pharmacist whisked powder and water together in what looked like a 40-gallon pasta pot, and medical students screwed caps onto the bottles.

The line can churn out 5,400 bottles a day, “and everything is automated except putting the caps on,” said Christopher Ntege, the chief pharmacist. “That is a small challenge compared to what we faced before.”

Despite its imperfections, the Ugandan model inspires others.

“Many countries come here to learn how they should rewrite their laws and medical policies,” said Dr. Emmanuel B.K. Luyirika, executive director of the African Palliative Care Association, an advocacy group. “This is a low-cost initiative that should be used everywhere.”

The health ministries of about 20 countries now use inexpensive morphine, Dr. Merriman estimated. But it is often available only in hospitals in the capital.

Efforts like these in Africa, Asia and Latin America “have laid the groundwork in the last twelve years for what could happen,” said Dr. Kathleen M. Foley, a palliative care specialist at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center.

“But it hasn’t moved faster because of poverty, lack of infrastructure, and the fact that palliative care is a new field and specialists aren’t paid by their governments to do the work.”

Now, she added, “I’m increasingly concerned that we’re losing the battle because of this panic. Overdose deaths are taking all the oxygen.”